In Defense of Creative Nonfiction

Needless to say, the creative nonfiction genre doesn’t have the best reputation among the more free-spirited reader community. 

Some studies suggest that people now stay focused on a single digital task for roughly 40–50 seconds, although research on attention span is debatable. 

The low focus level is why many people consider nonfiction in general, well, boring. It feels, at best, like reading a textbook or, worse, “aspire to perspire” type material. Needless to say, the creative nonfiction genre doesn’t have the best reputation among the more free-spirited reader community. 

Nonfiction is, as the name implies, based on true events. What separates creative nonfiction from the parent category inis its use of factual writing alongside literary techniques. 

For instance, Rich Dad Poor Dad by Robert Kiyosaki uses a character-driven approach to teach personal finance.

It frames financial lessons through personal experiences, adopting a more narrative, sharing-than-lecturing tone.

Also, the popular Christian motivational book An Enemy Called Average by John Mason uses short, attention-grabbing nuggets called mini-aphorisms to break down bigger ideas into bite-sized pieces.

The national bestseller also relies on anecdotes and a generally conversational tone. These two examples show that creative nonfiction is not as well loved as other genres despite producing recorded successful, compelling results.

The Evolution of Creative Nonfiction

Nonfiction has been in existence before the term was properly named. The earliest recorded forms of nonfiction were administrative records, receipts, and inventory lists produced by the Sumeriansin ancient Mesopotamia, dating back to approximately 3500–3000 BCE.

The Kish Tablet contains pictographic inscriptions in Mesopotamia that likely function as early administrative records. 

Creative nonfiction, on the other hand, dates back to prehistoric times. Prehistoric cave paintings, for example, recorded hunting scenes and daily life, serving as early forms of visual storytelling.

Ancient travel accounts largely existed in the works of classical writers such as Herodotus, Plutarch, and Tacitus, who recorded history with a literary, narrative focus.

Proponents

The more modern proponents of creative nonfiction are Michel de Montaigne, Joan Didion, and Truman Capote. 

Michel de Montaigne pioneered the personal essay. He published two volumes in 1580, followed by a third in 1588.

One factor that really stood out, especially for the 16th century, was the use of a mix of complete honesty and informality. 

Joan Didion was one of the founding voices in the evolution of journalism, elevating literary journalism by merging factual reporting with personal subjectivity, precise prose, and intense imagery.

Didion was known mostly for her lucid prose, in which she observed and reported on social unrest, especially in the 1960s.

The 1966 publication In Cold Blood by Truman Capote is considered a foundational text of the true-crime genre, pioneering the “nonfiction novel”. This amazing feat is possible through combining rigorous, in-depth reportage with the narrative structure and psychological depth of fiction.

Types of Creative Nonfiction

There is an assumption that the memoir is the only form of creative nonfiction, which is incorrect. Nonfiction is a wide genre that includes many sub-genres, including:

1. Memoir

A memoir is a nonfiction first-person narrative that focuses on a specific, pivotal period or theme in the author’s life rather than their entire life story. An early example dates back to 50–52 BCE with Julius Caesar’s Commentaries on the Gallic Wars (Commentarii de Bello Gallico). 

Nowadays, the memoir has gotten a facelift, with modern versions such as Trevor Noah’s Born a Crime, which draws on his stories from his South African childhood and includes necessary social commentary.

2. Personal Essay

A personal essay is a short, nonfiction work of autobiographical writing that shares a story from the author’s life, focusing on personal experience, reflection, and growth. 

Modern adaptations of the personal essay include Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s Notes on Grief and Sakeenah Kareem’s What Being Disabled Taught Me About Nigerians. 

3. Literary Journalism

Literary journalism is a form of nonfiction writing that utilizes narrative, stylistic, and structural techniques commonly associated with fiction, such as scene-setting, character development, and immersive description, while adhering to strict factual accuracy.

Daniel Defoe’s A Journal of the Plague Year, often labeled as a proto–literary journalism work, is one of the earliest examples of creative nonfiction.

Still, the genre currently includes impactful work such as Slouching Towards Bethlehem (1968) by Joan Didion and The Warmth of Other Suns (2010) by Isabel Wilkerson.

4. Narrative History

Narrative history is the practice of writing history in a story-based form, focusing on telling a compelling, chronological tale of past events rather than relying solely on analytical or thematic structures.

The earliest example of narrative history is The Stele of the Vultures.

Books such as Fall and Rise: The Story of 9/11 by Mitchell Zuckoff and There Was a Country: A Personal History of Biafra by Chinua Achebe demonstrate the art form’s continued vitality.

5. Travel Writing

Travel writing is a nonfiction genre documenting personal journeys, focusing on immersion in a place’s culture, people, and atmosphere.

One of the earliest recorded forms of travel writing was Herodotus’s account of the cultures, traditions, and geography of the Mediterranean, Egypt, and Western Asia in The Histories.

The Creative Nonfiction Elements

Truthful foundation 

The backbone of creative nonfiction is factual accuracy. The events, people, and experiences must be true for a work of written art to be dubbed as “nonfiction.” 

For instance, In Cold Blood is based on the real 1959 murders of the Clutter family in Holcomb, Kansas.

Narrative structure 

The structure of creative nonfiction, however, borrows elements from fiction writing, such as plot, pacing, imagery, narrative techniques, and story arcs. 

Nice Girls Don’t Get the Corner Office features the typical problem, situation, and resolution storytelling format, prevalent in fiction.

Authorial voice

Here, the writer’s perspective really shines through. The tone could either be reflective or personal.

James Clear’s Atomic Habits uses a distinctive, somewhat conversational tone with personal anecdotes. 

Why Some Readers Think It’s Boring

The core reason why creative nonfiction generally boils down to bad writing. 

The goal of any literature is to engage the readers to the point they become fans, or at the very least, positive promoters of the material in question. Some of the specific reasons for the unpopularity of nonfiction are

Association with academic essays or textbooks

Nonfiction is too often linked to academic essays and texts, and rightly so. A significant percentage of nonfiction follows a more rigid format that many people do not enjoy.

However, there are genuinely interesting nonfiction books. 

The international bestseller, The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck, shares principles for living using personal anecdotes, a humorous conversational tone, and storytelling elements to capture the reader’s attention.

Some works prioritize information over storytelling

The aim of creative nonfiction is to tell the truth in an engaging, literary manner, blending facts with narrative. Unfortunately, in some nonfiction books, focus on sharing information without organizing it in a way readers want to see. 

The result is highly educative material, akin to an academic essay. This style of writing is mostly prevalent in instruction manuals and self-help guides.

Readers may expect fiction-level imagination

Fiction is full of unpredictability that readers love. Sadly, nonfiction doesn’t work that way. Everything follows a clear, safe progression that the audience may not enjoy. But the rules are the rules.

Because creative nonfiction is based on facts, there isn’t room for imaginative world-building or explosive twists, which is often a constraint on audience satisfaction.

That is, unless one finds themselves reading an autobiography of a deeply adventurous individual such as I’m Glad My Mom Died by Jennette McCurdy.

The former child star talks about her family dynamic, especially with her mother, using vivid scene construction, character arcs, dialogue reframing, proper pacing, and emotional depth that reads like great fiction rather than a memoir. 

A Genre Still Redefining Itself

Now that all is said and done, it begs the question: Is creative nonfiction mislabelled? Or is it truly as boring and pretentious as many believe? Yes.

The genre is misrepresented, and it does include work that is boring and pretentious. But a few bad eggs shouldn’t affect the perception of such an expansive specialization. 

Ultimately, books such as Born a Crime, Nice Girls Don’t Get the Corner Office, I’m Glad My Mom Died, and The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck show that the creative nonfiction genre is evolving and will continue to remain relevant.